Designer Tips for a Timeless Kitchen Renovation
Welcome to the heart of our home—our newly completed St. Charles Colonial kitchen renovation! If you’re here to uncover the specifics of our classic kitchen design—like the warm white painted cabinets (Sherwin Williams Greek Villa, by the way) or the stunning countertops (LX Hausys Lumina Quartz)—you’re in the right place.
But before diving into all the details that make this space timeless, I’d love to share the story of how this special kitchen came to be. As an interior designer based in Chicago, IL, I’ll walk you through our renovation journey, highlighting key choices and sharing tips to help you achieve this classic look in your own home.
Whether you’re planning a kitchen renovation in Chicago or just gathering ideas, I hope this post inspires and guides you along the way!
Creating an Open, Inviting Space
From the moment we walked into this house, I saw so much potential. It wasn’t Pinterest-perfect, but it had the classic Colonial charm I’d always dreamed of for our forever home. I could already picture the kitchen as a bright, cozy space where we’d cook, share meals, and welcome friends and family.
At the time, though, it felt closed off and compartmentalized. The kitchen wasn’t the heart of the home I envisioned—but I knew it could be.
My top priority was to make the kitchen feel open, warm, and connected to the rest of our home. Before the renovation, it was dark and closed off, with no access to the beautiful light from our living room. Removing one wall—bold but worth it—transformed it into the bright, inviting space I had imagined.
Now, it’s where we gather, share meals, and chat about our day. It’s the spot for everyday moments that make a house feel like home. It’s truly the heart of our home
If you’re planning a kitchen renovation in Chicago and dreaming of that classic charm—I’d love to help you create a space that feels meaningful and welcoming. Designing a kitchen with timeless touches is one of the best ways to ensure your space grows beautifully with you and your family. With thoughtful choices, you can create a kitchen that feels fresh, functional, and inviting for years to come.
For those of you here for a bit of inspiration or DIY ideas, here are my top 15 tips for designing a timeless kitchen that’s both stylish and built to last!
1. Embrace Classic Cabinetry Styles
When designing a classic kitchen, cabinetry truly sets the tone—it’s where style and functionality come together. As a Chicago-based interior designer, I always recommend investing in the best cabinets your budget allows. High-quality plywood is often a good way to go—it’s durable, cost-effective, and not only elevates the space but also stands up to daily wear, proving its worth for years to come.
Next, you’ll want to decide between stock, semi-custom, or custom cabinets. Each option has its benefits, but when we design a kitchen, we think through every little detail, from the crown molding to the toe-kicks. That’s what makes it feel like a designer-grade kitchen remodel!
For aesthetics, I’m all about timeless door choices, like inset shaker cabinets with just the right amount of character. Beveled or beaded edges, along with sleek slab-top drawers, add a blend of charm and durability. A well-crafted full-overlay cabinet door is another fantastic option. These styles work beautifully in both traditional and modern homes. I also love incorporating unique toe-kick designs to elevate the space or omitting the toe-kick in non-work areas to give a furniture-like appearance.
Classic cabinetry design involves countless details, each contributing to the overall picture. As an interior designer in Chicago IL, I can help you navigate these decisions, ensuring a perfect balance between your style and the functionality your space needs.
The Best Warm White Kitchen Cabinet Color: Sherwin Williams Greek Villa
In the St. Charles Colonial kitchen, we chose semi-custom inset shaker-style cabinets featuring a subtle bead detail and a beaded frame, painted in Sherwin Williams’ Greek Villa. This warm white paint color beautifully complements the space, adding a classic and inviting touch.
This creamy, warm white paint color brings a cozy touch and adds a soft contrast to the crisp Sherwin Williams Pure White walls—my favorite clean, neutral white. Together, they create a welcoming and classic look that feels timeless and effortlessly stylish.
Other timeless cabinet door styles I love include flat-panel, cottage, and glass-front cabinets. Flat-panel doors offer a clean, minimalist look that’s perfect for a sleek, modern feel. Cottage cabinetry brings a warm, farmhouse charm that’s always inviting. Glass-front cabinets add a light, airy touch, allowing you to showcase your favorite pieces and create a sense of openness.
Each of these options has its unique charm, helping to create a timeless kitchen that’s not only beautiful but also welcoming and functional.
2. Create a Functional Layout with Family Flow in Mind
As an interior designer in Chicago IL, I know that a functional layout is key to creating a classic kitchen design. It’s about more than just fitting everything in—it’s about designing a space that truly works for the way your family lives. I always take the time to consider how the kitchen will be used daily and how it should flow with the rest of the home. When planning, my focus is always on the essentials: the sink, stove, and fridge. Arranging these in the classic “work triangle” is such a simple yet effective approach. It’s a layout that’s stood the test of time because it keeps everything within reach, making cooking feel effortless and turning family moments in the kitchen into something truly enjoyable.
In our St. Charles Colonial project, we took a bit of a leap by removing a wall to enhance both the style and function of the space. I knew this would open up so many possibilities. By repositioning the sink to face the living room, centering the range, and finding just the right spot for the fridge, we created a layout that makes cooking a breeze and, more importantly, fosters connection in the space. The kitchen feels more open, more connected to the rest of the home, and, at the same time, incredibly warm and inviting. It’s all about finding that balance between function and style, and this project truly reflects that.
I’ve always believed that the best kitchens are the ones that not only look great but also fit perfectly into the daily rhythm of family life. When every piece of the layout is thoughtfully considered, the kitchen becomes a space where everything flows—and where memories are made.
3. Add Character with Lighting
In a classic kitchen design, layered lighting is everything—it transforms the room’s feel and keeps it functional for daily tasks. I love combining task, ambient, and accent lighting to bring warmth and an inviting ambiance to the space. Timeless choices, like brass pendants and vintage-inspired sconces, add enduring charm, while modern touches, such as adjustable Kelvin can lights, give the flexibility to adapt the lighting throughout the day.
Good lighting can make or break a kitchen. When possible, I always recommend investing in quality fixtures. It’s a worthwhile investment for both style and function. For those working within a tighter budget, I suggest balancing a few affordable pieces with a standout fixture, like a beautiful pendant, to elevate the room’s look.
In the St. Charles Colonial kitchen, I selected these beautiful brass lantern pendants—truly a classic choice. Paired with white plaster sconces and a Serena and Lily wicker flush mount, each piece introduces a mix of textures and depth, blending style with functionality.
Task lighting is equally important; under-cabinet and prep area lighting is essential for everyday use. Adding dimmers lets us control the lighting intensity, setting the right mood for any time of day and giving the kitchen warmth and character that feel welcoming yet refined.
4. Go Timeless with Flooring
Just like cabinetry, flooring is an investment you’ll live with for a long time, so it’s important to go classic and choose something that will stand the test of time. When choosing flooring for your kitchen, white oak is a timeless choice—and it’s also hugely on trend right now. Its soft texture and durability make it perfect for a kitchen, giving the space a grounded, natural feel. The wood’s subtle grain adds character without overpowering the room. White oak works well in many styles, from colonial to modern farmhouse. Whether you choose wide planks or a pattern like herringbone (as we did in our foyer!), white oak fits a variety of aesthetics.
If a full replacement isn’t in the cards for your budget, refinishing your existing wood flooring is often a more affordable and sustainable choice. For the St. Charles Colonial, we refinished the original red oak floors and staircase. We started by sanding down to the raw wood, then topped it off with two coats of Bona Nordic and one coat of Bona HD High Traffic finish. The result? A beautiful, fresh white oak look that ties the entire design together seamlessly.
For other timeless options, I love Minwax’s Provincial, Special Walnut, Jacobean, Early American, and English Chestnut, as well as Varathane’s Briarsmoke, Kona, and Honey Maple. These rich tones add depth and sophistication to any space.
5. Incorporate Open Shelving or Glass Features
Open shelving and glass-front cabinets are such a beautiful way to elevate a kitchen. They break up the lines of long cabinetry, making the space feel larger, brighter, and more inviting. Plus, they give you the perfect opportunity to showcase your favorite dishes, cookbooks, or treasured vintage finds—something I truly love to do!
Appliance garage-style doors are another clever solution. They let you keep your space open and airy or tuck everything away when needed—perfect for those busy days when practicality is key, and a little tidying up makes all the difference.
In our St. Charles Colonial, the arched pantry features white oak floating shelves that bring such an open, airy feel to the small but mighty space. They add warmth and texture without feeling heavy, and the natural grain offers just enough character without overpowering the design. The floating design gives a modern, functional touch that’s simple yet impactful, creating a sense of calm and spaciousness in the kitchen.
I’ve always had a soft spot for displaying beautiful dishes. That’s why we chose ceiling-to-counter cabinets with glass doors on either side of the range in our St. Charles Colonial. These glass-front cabinets became the focal point of the main kitchen, adding elegance while maintaining a timeless, classic feel. The symmetry brings balance to the room, blending beauty and function in a way that works perfectly for our family.
6. Incorporate Architectural Details
When planning a timeless Chicago kitchen renovation, start by looking around your home! A kitchen should blend seamlessly with your home’s existing architecture, becoming a natural extension of its character. If your home lacks that charm or you’re starting fresh, adding classic design details is key.
Consider the moldings— from the crown to the toe kick or baseboards—this is what elevates a project from DIY to designer-grade. Elegant moldings, intricate millwork, and arched entryways evoke warmth and character. White oak doors, cozy nooks, and vertical shiplap or beadboard add texture, while simple ledges, top molding, or a peg rail offer clever storage that feels effortlessly chic.
In our St. Charles Colonial kitchen, every detail was designed to feel as though it had always been part of the home, preserving its unique charm. By embracing the colonial spirit through carefully chosen trim, millwork, and timeless hardware, the kitchen now flows effortlessly with the rest of the house. From the refined cabinet profiles to custom finishes, each element reflects the classic design we cherish.
7. Plan for Practical Kitchen Seating
Your kitchen should be more than just a place to cook—it should be where your family gathers. Whether it’s a cozy breakfast nook or a homework station, seating plays a big role in the layout. Classic options like upholstered banquettes or wooden barstools offer both comfort and style, keeping your kitchen timeless and welcoming.
Seating is key in kitchen design, especially in family homes. Whether it’s a large island or a breakfast nook, blending function with style is essential.
In our previous home, we found we were a “breakfast at the island” family. So, in our recent Chicago kitchen renovation, we skipped the traditional table and went big with the island. At first, it felt risky, but I’m so glad we did it! Now, we can enjoy a stunning view of the classic arched pantry doorway while sharing meals. This choice enhances the kitchen’s beauty and creates a welcoming space for family moments. After all, that’s what it’s about—designing a space where we can truly connect.
Here’s a little designer tip for you – a great guideline is to space standard counter stools about 24 inches apart along your island. This ensures ample seating space and a balanced layout.
8. Choose Quality Countertops Like Natural Stone
In a timeless kitchen, natural materials take center stage. I always recommend opting for a natural, durable material in a neutral tone to keep the space timeless. Countertops like marble, granite, quartz, and solid wood bring elegance and durability, aging beautifully over time. Marble and soapstone, with their unmatched beauty, elevate any space, adding a refined, welcoming sophistication and warmth.
When it comes to family-friendly kitchen renovations, practicality is just as important as style. That’s where high-end marble-like quartz comes in. We chose LX Hausys Lumina for our kitchen, and it’s been a favorite ever since. It combines stunning looks with functionality, making it perfect for busy families. If you love the natural stone aesthetic but want to skip the maintenance, leathered soapstone-style quartz is a fantastic option. It delivers that luxurious vibe with less upkeep. For a more refined choice, Taj Mahal-style quartzite blends beauty and durability, offering the perfect mix of form and function. And don’t overlook porcelain countertops, which are having a major moment. With some of the most realistic marble finishes, porcelain is a smart pick for those looking for both beauty and practicality.
Ultimately, it’s about striking the right balance—something that’s as beautiful as it is durable. After all, the countertop is where all the magic happens, so it deserves extra attention!
9. Classic Hardware Finishes and Mixing Metals
Let’s dive into the world of classic hardware finishes and the joy of mixing metals! Adding different metal finishes can bring character and warmth to your space, but there are a few simple guidelines to keep in mind. I like to stick to two contrasting finishes for balance—think polished nickel paired with satin brass, chrome with matte black, or polished gold alongside antique bronze. Consistency is key, especially for plumbing fixtures. Keeping a single finish here helps maintain a cohesive look while allowing for personality.
As an interior designer in Chicago IL, I’m drawn to timeless kitchen finishes like unlacquered brass, satin brass, polished brass, polished nickel, and antique brass and bronze. In the St. Charles Colonial kitchen renovation, I chose satin brass for the lighting and hardware and antique brass for the plumbing. Normally, I wouldn’t mix two gold tones, but this pairing worked beautifully because they weren’t directly next to each other. The complementary tones added warmth and elegance without overwhelming the space.
While simplicity is always my go-to, sometimes trusting your instincts leads to something truly unique. A well-thought-out mix of metals can elevate your kitchen, bringing a sophisticated touch that feels both fresh and timeless. The key is to keep it balanced—so don’t be afraid to experiment!
10. Make the Range a Focal Point
A hood is both functional and a great way to elevate your kitchen design. A built-in wood hood adds timeless charm, often missing from builder-grade kitchens, and creates a striking focal point. It balances visual weight and brings symmetry to the space. In the St. Charles Colonial, we chose a sloped Hoodsly wood hood with classic trim, making modifications to the depth and height to fit our design. The hood was ordered primed and then custom-painted on-site to perfectly match our warm white Greek Villa cabinetry, creating a seamless look in the kitchen. It beautifully frames the range, adding warmth and character while drawing the eye upward. This design choice not only enhances the look but also improves the function of the space, tying everything together to create a cohesive, inviting, and timeless feel.
Hoods come in many styles, and Hoodsly is a great resource for a semi-custom option. Some of my favorites are the sloped, tapered, or curved designs. I also love a bell-shaped hood for a slightly more modern touch. Accents like trim packages or brass strapping can really elevate the overall look.
11. Stick with the Classics for Tile and Backsplashes
Don’t forget about the backsplash when planning your timeless kitchen! Whether you opt for classic subway tile or a more modern handmade design, this is the perfect opportunity to let your personality shine. Printed tiles are making a comeback and will likely continue to gain popularity. They add a unique touch that elevates the space.
If subway tile isn’t your style, beadboard or vertical shiplap also make for a stunning backsplash. These options bring texture and warmth, creating a charming, classic look that remains timeless. A trending choice is a slab backsplash made from your countertop material—it can make a bold statement! I love using a slab backsplash with interesting texture or veining for an eye-catching effect.
We wanted to add a modern twist in our St. Charles Colonial, so we selected a Riad Tile from The Tile Shop in a 4×4 square format, blending tradition with a contemporary flair. We love how it refreshed our classic kitchen.
Remember, there’s always room for a little creativity in your design—just keep it sparing to maintain balance and preserve that timeless charm!
12. Opt for Subtle, Timeless Wall Colors
When you’re lucky enough to have beautiful original elements like wood flooring or cabinetry, let them be the foundation of your design. In our space, we’ve embraced the beauty of our refinished red oak floors, which, in their current state, have a light, almost white oak-like finish. We paired the kitchen cabinet white paint in Sherwin Williams Greek Villa, a warm white, with the crisp white walls of Sherwin Williams Pure White. This choice of kitchen cabinet white paint allows the Greek Villa cabinetry to stand out with its warmth, while the Pure White walls create a fresh backdrop that complements the soft pink undertones of the red oak flooring without competing.
One thing I always recommend is building your color palette around something that already exists in your space—whether it’s flooring, cabinetry, or even an accent piece. Natural, warm colors are a timeless way to ensure your kitchen stays stylish for years to come. Shades like taupe, beige, navy, and even a touch of green offer classic staying power, allowing your space to feel current yet enduring. These hues work beautifully with wood tones and can carry your design through any trend.
I love Sherwin Williams for their white and neutral paint colors, perfect for both walls and kitchen cabinets. Some of my favorites include Pure White, Greek Villa, Natural Choice, Accessible Beige, Shoji White, Alabaster, and Snowbound—each offering a versatile backdrop for any design. For walls, Sherwin Williams Pure White is my go-to for its flexibility, no matter which direction the space faces. For kitchen cabinets, I highly recommend Sherwin Williams Greek Villa, the perfect creamy warm white that’s not too yellow.
A helpful tip: get white paint samples from Samplize and place them on your walls and kitchen cabinets. It’s a cleaner, more efficient way to see how the colors will interact with your space, and it’s just as affordable as traditional samples but with much less mess.
13. Invest in High-Quality Plumbing Components
In a timeless Chicago kitchen renovation, plumbing is one area where you should never compromise. The right plumbing—from the internal components to the faucets—can truly elevate the entire space. For that classic, traditional look, a gooseneck bridge faucet in unlacquered brass is always a winning choice.
For the St. Charles Colonial kitchen, I opted for antique brass. It offers the same elegant charm with a bit less upkeep. While unlacquered brass develops a lovely patina over time, I chose antique brass for its low-maintenance beauty.
When it comes to plumbing, consistency in finishes is key. I typically avoid mixing metals here. While it can work in rare cases, it’s best to know the rules before you break them. Keeping finishes consistent will give your kitchen a polished, cohesive feel.
14. Choose Durable, High-Quality Appliances
When it comes to appliances, always go for classic styles over trendy ones—these are significant investments! Stainless steel appliances or paneled fronts seamlessly blending with your cabinetry are timeless choices. They create a cohesive, elegant look and stand the test of time.
While it’s worth investing in high-end brands like Boche and Thermador for lasting quality, there are some great budget-friendly options as well. For example, Zline offers a fantastic 48-inch dual fuel range that’s hard to beat at its price point. If you’re looking for a splurge, a statement piece from La Cornue or Smeg can elevate your kitchen and serve as a beautiful centerpiece. Whatever you choose, make sure it’s a design that will continue to serve you well for years to come!
15. Add Your Personal Touch
A timeless kitchen renovation is all about selecting elements that are both enduring and personal. It’s about choosing features that reflect your style and bring you joy each time you step into the space—whether it’s a unique backsplash shape, classic cremone pulls, or a cozy window seat upholstered in a traditional block print.
In the St. Charles Colonial, some of my favorite details include our Hoodsly hood, the classic white oak pocket door, and the charming arched pantry—details that I spent a long time perfecting. These features elevate the home’s design and are truly a blessing in our everyday lives.
This is also the perfect opportunity to experiment with some timeless trends. Skirted pantries are having a moment, as are cafe curtains and brass rails. These trends have staying power, so if they speak to you, don’t hesitate to incorporate them. Just remember—less is more when it comes to these special details!
Finally, infuse your personality into the space with art and decorative elements that hold meaning for you. Whether it’s vintage finds like a crock filled with utensils or a beautiful bowl of seasonal fruit in your grandmother’s crystal, these touches bring warmth and character to your kitchen. We’ve added personal details like framed family recipes, antique cutting boards, and a collection of our favorite cookbooks. These small, meaningful touches create a kitchen that’s not only functional but also filled with memories—making it truly the heart of our home.
A Classic Investment
A kitchen renovation with a timeless feel is an investment that pays off in so many ways. It’s a space that evolves gracefully alongside your family, growing with you through every season of life. A well-designed kitchen doesn’t just serve as a functional space—it becomes the backdrop for countless memories: family dinners, holiday gatherings, and quiet mornings over coffee. By embracing classic design principles, you’ll create a kitchen that feels as fresh and inviting in years to come as it does the day it’s completed.
Elevate Your Kitchen Renovation Experience in Chicago
If you’re in the Chicago Illinois area and looking to bring your dream kitchen to life with an interior designer, Tami O’Malley Design is here to guide you every step of the way. Specializing in custom kitchen design, organization, and cabinetry, we offer full-service design to help create a space that fits both your style and your family’s needs. From personalized consultations to custom design plans, we work with you to create a timeless kitchen that you’ll cherish for years. Let’s collaborate on your vision—reach out to Tami O’Malley Design today and begin your exciting journey to a more beautiful, functional kitchen!
